First-lesson review

A close look at the first minutes of lesson one.

Most learners decide in the first minutes of lesson one whether they will come back for lesson two. This page is about those minutes: a scorecard you can run on your own first lesson, and a review I do by hand for three lessons a month.

The scorecard

Eight checks for a first lesson.

Open your first lesson as a learner would, from the first screen, and answer each check with yes or no.

  1. Does the lesson say how long it takes?

    Look at the first screen. The learner should see the length in minutes before they start.

  2. Does the first activity come before any welcome, instructor bio, objectives list or platform tour?

    Look at everything that sits between the start button and the first thing the learner does.

  3. Does the learner do something with their hands in under five minutes?

    Run a stopwatch from the first screen to the first time they type, choose, sort or solve. Pressing Next does not count.

  4. Does a question or a scenario come before the explanation?

    Look for a problem the learner tries before they are taught the answer. In Richland, Kornell and Kao (2009), readers who tried to answer questions before reading remembered those answers better afterwards, even when their first attempts were wrong.

  5. After the first few minutes, is there a question the learner has to answer from memory?

    Look at how the answer is given. If the learner can get it right by spotting a sentence from the previous screen, the question only tests recognition. Roediger and Karpicke (2006) found that students who practised recalling a text remembered more of it a week later than students who reread it.

  6. Is there at least one option that someone with half an understanding would pick and get wrong?

    Look at the wrong options. Each one should come from a real misunderstanding. If every wrong option is plainly wrong, the question tells you nothing.

  7. Does the feedback say why an answer is wrong?

    Pick a wrong answer on purpose and read what comes back. A reply that only says the answer is incorrect and to try again does not count.

  8. Is there one clear thing the learner can do at the end that they could not do at the start?

    Finish the sentence “After this lesson you can…” with a verb that another person could watch you do.

Count the yes answers. Then start with the earliest no, because the checks follow the order of the lesson.

mostafafathy.com/first-lesson-review

Where the checks come from

Checks four and five rest on the pretesting and retrieval practice studies named above. Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) reviewed ten common study techniques and rated practice testing as one of the two with high utility. The scorecard as a whole follows what Robert Bjork calls desirable difficulties: some conditions that make practice feel harder also make the learning last longer. The other checks are design habits I have written about in my own articles and newsletter.

How the review works

Send one lesson. Get one page back.

Send
Send the first lesson of your course in a LinkedIn message, as a link or as a file. One lesson only, and it has to be the first one.
Three a month
I review three first lessons a month.
What comes back
One page of notes: where the lesson stands on the eight checks, and what I would change first.
Newsletter
A lesson may be described in my newsletter. No names are used: not yours, not the course's, not the organisation's.
Message me on LinkedIn

Who is reading it

Mostafa Fathy, Head of E-Learning. I lead a multidisciplinary e-learning team across instructional design, visual design, LMS, and AI engineering.